Marx, Engels and Ecology
AbstractThis is a brief survey of Marx and Engels’ views on ecology, from the viewpoint of their relevance for 21th Century ecosocialism. While there are some serious limitations in the way both consider the “development of productive forces”, there are powerfull insights in their discussion of the destructive consequences of capitalist expansion for the environment - an expansion that generates a disastrous metabolic rift in the exchanges between human societies and nature. Some ecological Marxists distinguish between “first stage ecosocialists” - who believe that Marx analyses on ecological issues are too incomplete and dated to be of real relevance today - and “second stage ecosocialists” that emphasize the contemporary methodological significance of Marx’s ecological critique of capitalism. This paper tries to argue for a third position (which probably could be accepted by several people of the two groups above): Marx and Engels discussion on ecological issues is incomplete and dated, but inspite these shortcomings, it has real relevance and methodological significance today.
Burkett, Paul, 2009. Ecological Economics. Toward a Red and Green Political Economy, Chicago, Haymarket Books.
Engels, Friedrich, 1959. Anti-Dühring, Moscow, Progress Publishers.
Engels, Friedrich, 1964. Dialectics of Nature, Moscow, Progress Publishers,
Foster, John Bellamy, 2001. Marx’s Ecology. Materialism and Nature, N.York, Monthly Review Press.
Foster, John Bellamy, 2010. "Marx's Grundrisse and the Ecology of Capitalism", in J.B. Foster, Brett Clark and Richard York, The Ecological Rift, Capitalism's War on Earth, New York, Monthly Review Press.
Kovel, Joel, 2007. The Enemy of Nature, New York, Zed Books.
Marx, Karl, 1964. Zur Kritik der politischen Ökonomie, Vorwort, Marx Engels Werke (MEW), Berlin, Dietz Verlag, vol. 13.
Marx, Karl, 1965. "Kritik des Gothaer Programms", MEW, vol. 19.
Marx, Karl, 1968. Das Kapital, vol. I, MEW vol. 23.
Marx, Karl, 1968. Das Kapital, vol. II, MEW vol. 24.
Marx, Karl, 1968. Das Kapital, vol. III, MEW vol. 25.
Marx, Karl, 1970. Capital, New York, Vintage, vol. I.
Marx, Karl, 1973. Grundrisse, New York, Vintage.
Marx, Karl, 1975a. Manuscripts of 1844, in Early Writings, New York, Vintage.
Marx, Karl, Engels, Friedrich, 1975b. Communist Manifesto in Collected Works, New York, International Publishers, vol. 6.
Marx, Karl, 1981. Capital, New York, Vintage, vol. III.
Saito, Kohei, 2016. "Marx's Ecological Notebooks", Monthly Review, vol.67, n° 9